The product locks a critical resource more times than intended, leading to an unexpected state in the system.
Extended Description
When a product is operating in a concurrent environment and repeatedly locks a critical resource, the consequences will vary based on the type of lock, the lock's implementation, and the resource being protected. In some situations such as with semaphores, the resources are pooled and extra locking calls will reduce the size of the total available pool, possibly leading to degraded performance or a denial of service. If this can be triggered by an attacker, it will be similar to an unrestricted lock (CWE-412). In the context of a binary lock, it is likely that any duplicate locking attempts will never succeed since the lock is already held and progress may not be possible.
ThreatScore
Threat Mapped score: 1.9
Industry: Finiancial
Threat priority: P3 - Important (Medium)
Observed Examples (CVEs)
No observed examples available.
Related Attack Patterns (CAPEC)
N/A
Attack TTPs
N/A
Modes of Introduction
Phase
Note
Implementation
N/A
Common Consequences
Impact: DoS: Resource Consumption (CPU), DoS: Crash, Exit, or Restart, Unexpected State — Notes:
Potential Mitigations
Implementation: When locking and unlocking a resource, try to be sure that all control paths through the code in which the resource is locked one or more times correspond to exactly as many unlocks. If the software acquires a lock and then determines it is not able to perform its intended behavior, be sure to release the lock(s) before waiting for conditions to improve. Reacquire the lock(s) before trying again. (N/A)
Applicable Platforms
None listed.
Demonstrative Examples
N/A
Notes
Maintenance: An alternate way to think about this weakness is as an imbalance between the number of locks / unlocks in the control flow. Over the course of execution, if each lock call is not followed by a subsequent call to unlock in a reasonable amount of time, then system performance may be degraded or at least operating at less than peak levels if there is competition for the locks. This entry may need to be modified to reflect these concepts in the future.